Training a stubborn dog can be a challenge, but the right training collar can make a big difference. A training collar provides a physical cue to the dog, helping them understand what is expected of them. The best training collar for a stubborn dog will depend on the individual dog and their specific training needs. Some common types of training collars include remote training collars, choke collars, martingale collars, head collars, and body harnesses. It’s important to choose a collar that is safe, humane, and appropriate for your dog’s size, age, and personality. When used correctly, a training collar can help you communicate with your dog and encourage good behavior.
What is a Shock Collar for Dogs?
A shock collar, also known as an e-collar or remote training collar, is a type of training collar that delivers an electrical stimulation to the dog’s neck. The shock is intended to get the dog’s attention and discourage unwanted behavior. The collar typically comes with a remote control that the owner can use to activate the shock.
Shock collars are controversial, and opinions on their use vary widely among animal behavior experts, trainers, and pet owners. Some people believe that shock collars are a safe and effective way to train dogs, while others consider them cruel and inhumane.
It’s important to note that shock collars should only be used as a last resort and under the supervision of a professional dog trainer. Improper use of shock collars can cause physical harm to the dog and damage the relationship between the dog and their owner. If you’re considering using a shock collar for your dog, it’s best to consult with a professional dog trainer to discuss other, more humane training options.
Can I Use a Shock Collar for Stubborn Dogs?
While shock collars can be effective in training some dogs, they are not recommended for use with stubborn dogs. Stubborn dogs can be particularly resistant to training, and using a shock collar can increase the likelihood of stress, anxiety, and aggression.
In addition, shock collars can be harmful to dogs if used improperly. The shock can cause physical pain, and the dog may associate the shock with the owner, leading to fear and mistrust.
Instead of a shock collar, consider using positive reinforcement training techniques, such as rewarding the dog for good behavior. This type of training helps to build a positive relationship between the dog and their owner, and it can be more effective in the long term.
If you are struggling with training a stubborn dog, it is best to consult with a professional dog trainer who can help you develop a training plan that is safe, effective, and humane.
While shock collars can be effective in training some dogs, they are not recommended for use with stubborn dogs. Stubborn dogs can be particularly resistant to training, and using a shock collar can increase the likelihood of stress, anxiety, and aggression.
In addition, shock collars can be harmful to dogs if used improperly. The shock can cause physical pain, and the dog may associate the shock with the owner, leading to fear and mistrust.
Instead of a shock collar, consider using positive reinforcement training techniques, such as rewarding the dog for good behavior. This type of training helps to build a positive relationship between the dog and their owner, and it can be more effective in the long term.
If you are struggling with training a stubborn dog, it is best to consult with a professional dog trainer who can help you develop a training plan that is safe, effective, and humane.
10 Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs
Here are our The 10 Best Vibrating Dog Collars
The Sportdog 425x Remote Training Dog Collar is a highly recommended training tool for stubborn dogs. This collar is suitable for dogs weighing over 8 lbs with a neck size of 5-22 inches. Despite its higher cost, many dog owners find that it is well worth the investment.
The Sportdog 425x offers a range of stimulation options, with three training modes: vibration, tone, and static stimulation. Additionally, it features three static stimulation levels (low, medium, and high) with 21 levels of intensity to choose from.
This e-collar is designed for both indoor and outdoor training, with a range of 500 yards (1500 ft). It is fully waterproof, with a submersible design that can withstand being submerged in 25 ft of water, making it a great choice for dogs who love to swim.
The Sportdog 425x remote can be used to train up to three dogs with the purchase of additional collars. The system is equipped with a long-lasting battery that can provide up to 50-70 hours of use, allowing for extended training sessions without interruption.
Overall, the Sportdog 425x’s wide range of stimulation options, excellent range, waterproof capabilities, and durability make it a top choice for dog owners looking to train their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- 3 ranges of static stimulation with 21 levels in each range!
- The collar receiver is waterproof
- 1500 ft range
Cons
- 3 ranges of static stimulation with 21 levels in each range!
- It’s quite difficult to adjust the settings
The PetSafe Gentle Leather Headcollar is a pet-approved and trainer-designed dog collar that provides a gentle solution for managing stubborn dogs. It features a padded neoprene nose loop that applies pressure to the back of the neck instead of the dog’s throat, preventing gagging or choking.
This headcollar is designed to gently prevent jumping and lunging in dogs. It is easy to put on, with an adjustable nose loop and quick-snap strap for a custom fit. The collar also comes with clear instructions for fitting and use, as well as a training DVD to assist the owner in the training process.
The PetSafe Gentle Leather Headcollar is suitable for even the largest dog breeds, with a weight capacity of up to 130 pounds. This collar is an excellent choice for pet owners who want a gentle and effective way to manage their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- Great to stop pulling
- Compatible with most breeds
Cons
- Absorbs odor
The Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar takes the second spot on the list of the best training collars for stubborn dogs. The Educator brand is well-known for its range of shock collars, and this model is no exception. Its unique stopwatch design makes it easy to operate, and it is suitable for dogs with neck sizes up to 30 inches.
The Educator E-Collar offers three training modes: beep, vibration, and shock, allowing the owner to choose the best training method for their dog. There are 100 levels of shock to choose from, as well as 60 booster levels for emergencies. The high static stimulation range is well-suited for even the most stubborn dogs.
The remote features a lock and set option, making it easy to set the correct stimulation level for your dog. The 2640 ft (1/2 mile) range makes this collar ideal for long-distance training. Both the collar receiver and the transmitter are fully waterproof, ensuring that they are protected in wet conditions.
The remote also includes a useful LED light feature, which allows you to spot your dog in low visibility conditions. The Educator E-Collar is available in both one and two-dog systems, and while the training system comes with one collar, additional collars can be purchased separately. The remote trainer is equipped with rechargeable lithium batteries that can be fully charged in just 2 hours, providing long-lasting power for extended training sessions.
Pros
- The collar has a LED light
- Long-range of 2640 ft
- Fully waterproof e-collar and remote
- 100 stimulation levels with 60 booster levels
Cons
- It can be a bit confusing to use the remote for the first time
The Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar is a versatile and effective training tool for stubborn dogs. This collar is designed for medium to large dogs weighing over 15 lbs.
The Pet Resolve collar offers three training modes: tone, vibration, and shock, giving the owner the ability to choose the most suitable method for their dog. With 10 levels of continuous and momentary stimulation, owners can select the best level for their dog’s needs. Additionally, the continuous stimulation mode delivers 1-8 seconds of non-stop stimulation, making it useful in emergency situations.
A unique feature of the Pet Resolve collar is the option to completely remove the shock mode by replacing the metal prongs with plastic prongs. This allows owners to train their dogs using only tone and vibration modes. Once basic behaviors have been learned, the shock mode can be reintroduced.
The Pet Resolve collar has a range of 3960 ft (3/4 mile), making it suitable for indoor, outdoor, and long-distance training. The collar is completely waterproof, allowing the dog to swim and bathe while wearing it, and the remote is splashproof, making it usable in any weather.
This remote trainer is capable of training up to three dogs at once with the purchase of additional collars. It also features a built-in night light, making it ideal for use with dogs who are let out at night, and an anti-bark mode, making it an excellent choice for dogs who bark excessively. Overall, the Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar is a great option for pet owners looking to train their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- Can completely remove the shock mode
- Inbuilt anti-bark function to control excessive barking
- 3960 ft range
- Night light for low visibility conditions
Cons
- Take a few seconds of pressing to turn on/off the remote
The Garmin Delta Xc is another excellent remote training collar for stubborn dogs. It offers three training modes (tone, vibration, and shock) and 18 intensities of shock, allowing owners to find the best training method for their dog. The collar also offers the option between continuous and momentary stimulation, with continuous stimulation being useful in emergency situations.
The remote has a simple, 3-button layout, making it easy to use, and an LCD screen display. The 2640 ft range makes this collar ideal for long-distance field training and indoor corrections.
Both the handheld remote and the dog collar are IPX7 waterproof, making this system perfect for water-loving dogs. The remote is a multi-dog training system, and up to three dogs can be trained simultaneously with the purchase of additional collars.
The rechargeable lithium batteries in the receiver and the transmitter have great battery life, providing long and effective training sessions. The handheld remote holds a single charge for 80 hours, while the collar has a battery life of 60 hours. The Garmin Delta Xc is a great choice for pet owners who want a reliable and effective remote training collar for their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- IPX7 waterproof collar and remote
- (2640 ft) half mile range
- Good battery life
- Can train up to three dogs
Cons
- There are signal issues at longer ranges
The Petspy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar is a versatile training tool that is adjustable to fit dogs of all breeds between 10-140 lbs. With tone, vibration, and shock modes, and 16 levels of shock, owners can easily find the best stimulation for their dog.
The collar has a 1950 ft range, making it ideal for both indoor and outdoor training. The handheld remote is user-friendly, with a simple layout that allows owners to focus on their dog rather than the remote.
The Petspy P620 is 100% waterproof, making it suitable for use in rainy weather and for dogs that love water. The training system is expandable to train two dogs at once with the purchase of additional collars.
The collar also features a dual fast charging system, allowing the remote and collar to be charged quickly. With every purchase, owners will receive a free e-book on dog training, making it a great resource for new dog owners. The Petspy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar is an excellent option for pet owners who want a reliable and effective training tool for their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- 100% waterproof collar
- Easily operable remote
- 1950 ft range
Cons
- The collar can stop charging at times
The Patpet Dog Shock Collar is a great option for pet owners who want a training collar with a long range. The adjustable collar fits dogs between 8-120 lbs with neck sizes of 7-25 inches and is lightweight, making it suitable for puppies as well.
The e-collar has three training modes, including 16 levels of shock and vibration, and tone modes, allowing owners to choose the safest and most effective training method for their dog. With a range of 3000 ft, this collar is ideal for long-distance and field training.
The collar and transmitter are both 100% waterproof, with the collar receiver being IPX7 waterproof and the transmitter being IPX5 rainproof. This makes it suitable for use in rainy weather and with water-loving dogs. The collar can also be used to train two dogs simultaneously with the purchase of an additional collar.
The remote has a simple design with just three buttons, allowing owners to easily distinguish between them by touch. The remote also has a security switch to prevent accidental shocks and a rapid charging system that fully charges in just 2 hours. The remote has 60 days of standby battery life, while the collar has 30 days of standby battery life.
In conclusion, the Patpet Dog Shock Collar is a great choice for pet owners looking for a safe, effective, and versatile training tool for their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- 3000 ft range
- Good battery life
- IPX7 waterproof e-collar receiver and IPX5 water-resistant remote
- Security switch to prevent accidental shocks
Cons
- The LCD screen is not clear in daylight
How to Choose the Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs?
When choosing a training collar for a stubborn dog, there are several factors to consider:
Range: The range of the collar refers to the maximum distance between the collar and the remote control. Consider a collar with a long range if you plan to use it for outdoor training or have a large property.
Training Modes: Look for a collar that offers multiple training modes such as tone, vibration, and shock. This way, you can choose the most effective and humane training method for your dog.
Shock Levels: Look for a collar that offers a range of shock levels, so you can choose the appropriate level of stimulation for your dog.
Waterproofing: If you plan to use the collar in wet conditions or with a dog that loves water, consider a collar that is waterproof.
Battery Life: Consider the battery life of the collar and the remote. Choose a collar with a long battery life to avoid interruptions during training sessions.
Safety Features: Look for a collar that has safety features such as a security switch to prevent accidental shocks.
Size: Make sure to choose a collar that fits your dog properly. Consider the weight and neck size of your dog when choosing a collar.
Ease of Use: Look for a collar that is easy to use and understand. A simple and intuitive remote control will make training easier and more efficient.
Durability: Choose a collar that is made from high-quality materials and is built to last.
Cost: Consider the cost of the collar and any additional accessories you may need, such as extra collars for multiple dogs.
Remember, the most important factor is the safety and well-being of your dog. Choose a training collar that is humane, effective, and safe.
The Final Say on the Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs
The best training collar for a stubborn dog will depend on the individual needs and characteristics of the dog and the owner. Consider the factors discussed above when choosing a training collar and look for a collar that is humane, effective, and safe.
It’s important to remember that training collars should only be used as a supplement to positive reinforcement training. Positive reinforcement training focuses on rewarding good behavior rather than punishing bad behavior. Using a training collar in conjunction with positive reinforcement training can provide the most effective and humane training experience for your dog.
Ultimately, the most important thing is to choose a training collar that fits your dog and your training goals. With the right training collar, you can help your stubborn dog become a well-behaved and obedient companion.
3 thoughts on “Top 7 Effective Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs”